Hard and expert puzzles
How to solve hard sudoku
Hard puzzles aren’t about guessing. They’re about a few more patterns, and a methodical way of looking for them.
A hard sudoku is one where the basic moves run out. You’ve placed every number you can by scanning, and the grid still has plenty of gaps. From here you need full pencil marks, a set of patterns to look for, and an order to look for them in.
Keep complete, accurate pencil marks
Hard puzzles are almost impossible without candidates. Once the easy numbers are in:
- Write every possible candidate in every empty square. Don’t skip any.
- Each time you place a number, erase it from the other squares in that row, column, and box.
- Each time a technique crosses out a candidate, erase it right away.
A single missing or stale candidate can hide the next move, or point you toward a wrong one. Our guide to pencil marks without the mess has a tidy system for paper.
Work through techniques in order
Always try the simplest techniques first. Every time something changes, go back to the top of the list. Easy moves often open up after a hard one.
- Singles: Full House, Hidden Single, Naked Single.
- Intersections: Pointing and Claiming.
- Pairs and triples: Naked Pair, Hidden Pair, Naked Triple, and Hidden Triple.
- One-number patterns: X-Wing, Skyscraper, 2-String Kite, Empty Rectangle, and Swordfish.
- Wings: Y-Wing, XYZ-Wing, and W-Wing.
- Chains: Simple Coloring and XY-Chain.
Most newspaper puzzles labeled “hard” or “tough” need nothing past step 3. Puzzles labeled “diabolical,” “fiendish,” or “expert” often need steps 4 to 6. Our guide to sudoku difficulty levels explains what those labels usually mean.
A worked example: where can the next 8 go?
Look at the top-left box. Follow just the 8s: the 8 already in row 2 rules out that row, and the 8 in column 3 rules out that column. Column 2 is no help either: its top square holds a 3, its middle square is in the blocked row, and its bottom square holds a 2.
You don’t yet know which of those two squares holds the 8. But either choice puts the 8 in column 1. So erase the penciled 8 from rows 7, 8 and 9 of that column. Leave both candidates in the box alone.
That’s a pointing pair. After each erasure, check the square again. If just one candidate survives, see how to place a naked single. If a digit has just one spot left in the box, see the Hidden Single walkthrough.
Look at one number at a time
Many hard techniques, such as X-Wing and Simple Coloring, are about a single number. With all nine candidates showing, they’re very hard to see. Instead, pick one number and look only at where it can go. Some players lightly shade those squares, or redraw that one number on a spare grid.
Numbers that are already placed six or seven times are the best candidates for these patterns, because they have few spots left.
Look for squares with two candidates
Squares with only two candidates are where pairs, Y-Wings, and XY-Chains come from. When you’re stuck, scan for them and ask how they connect. If two of them see each other and share a number, follow what happens if one is true, then if the other is.
Check your work before going deeper
Before reaching for an advanced technique, make sure nothing is wrong. On a hard puzzle, one mistake can make the rest of the grid look impossible. The warning signs, and how to catch them, are in common mistakes on paper.
What about guessing?
Guessing, or trial and error, does work: pick a candidate, follow it, and back up if you hit a contradiction. But it’s slow on paper, and it doesn’t teach you anything for the next puzzle. Every technique on this site is a shortcut for a specific kind of reasoning, so you can skip the guessing.
Beyond these techniques
The very hardest puzzles can call for still more. A Unique Rectangle uses the rule that a puzzle has only one answer, and an X-Chain follows one number through a long chain of two-spot links. See the full technique library.
Questions
What is the hardest sudoku technique?
There’s no single hardest one. Techniques get more general as they go: from singles, to pairs, to patterns like X-Wing, to chains that can be any length. Chains are usually the last thing a hard newspaper puzzle needs.
Do I need to learn every technique?
No. The techniques on our techniques page handle the large majority of published puzzles, including most labeled expert.
Can I check my progress without seeing the answer?
Yes. In the app, Check my work points out numbers that can’t be right and explains why, without showing the right ones.