Sudoku technique 13 of 21 · Advanced

Empty Rectangle

A box’s spots on a cross, plus one two-spot line. A box whose spots for a number lie on a cross, plus a row or column with only two spots, rules the number out of one square.

Often shortened to “ER.”

Step by step: Empty Rectangle on a real puzzle

  1. Empty Rectangle, step 1: When a box’s spots for a number all sit on one row and one column, it can team up with a two-spot line.

    When a box’s spots for a number all sit on one row and one column, it can team up with a two-spot line.

    Look at the 4s in box 4.

  2. Empty Rectangle, step 2: Every 4 in box 4 is in row 4 or column 1.

    Every 4 in box 4 is in row 4 or column 1.

    The spots are row 4, columns 1 and 2, and row 5, column 1. Together they make a cross.

  3. Empty Rectangle, step 3: Row 2 has only two spots for a 4: columns 1 and 8.

    Row 2 has only two spots for a 4: columns 1 and 8.

    If row 2, column 1 is the 4, column 1 is used up, so box 4 must put its 4 in row 4.

  4. Empty Rectangle, step 4: Either way, row 4, column 8 can’t be 4.

    Either way, row 4, column 8 can’t be 4.

    If row 2, column 8 is the 4, it shares column 8 with this square. If not, box 4’s 4 is in row 4, which this square shares too.

Empty Rectangle

Watch video

An Empty Rectangle starts with a box. Inside it, every spot for a number lies on one row or one column of the box, never in the other four squares. Those four empty squares form the rectangle that gives the pattern its name.

On its own that doesn’t rule anything out. But add a row or column elsewhere with only two spots for the number, one of which lines up with the box’s row or column, and you can cross the number out of a single square.

How to spot it

  1. Pick one number and look at a box where it has two to five spots.
  2. Check whether all of those spots fit on one row plus one column of the box. If they’re all on a single line, that’s Pointing instead.
  3. Look for a row or column outside the box with exactly two spots for the number, where one spot lines up with the box’s row or column.
  4. Follow the other spot of that pair to the box’s other line. Where they cross, the number can be crossed out.

Why it works

Take the line with two spots. If the spot that lines up with the box holds the number, it blocks that line of the box, so the box has to put its number on its other line. If it doesn’t, the pair’s other spot holds the number. Either way, the target square sees the number: either the far spot of the pair, or the box’s line. So it can’t hold the number itself.

Common mistakes

  • Spots off the cross. Every spot in the box must be on the chosen row or column. One stray spot breaks the pattern.
  • A pair with more than two spots. The outside row or column needs exactly two spots for the number.
  • Crossing out inside the box. The square you clear is always outside the box.

Questions

Does the box need four empty squares?

It needs four squares without the number, off the row and column. The squares can be filled or not; what matters is that the number can’t go there.

Is this a chain?

In a sense. It’s a short chain that uses the whole box as one link. That’s why it sits between the 2-String Kite and longer chains in difficulty.

Get the app