Guide · 3 min read

Choosing a puzzle book level

What “gentle,” “tough,” and “diabolical” usually mean.

Walk past any puzzle shelf and you’ll see sudoku books labeled every way imaginable: easy, gentle, moderate, medium, tough, hard, fiendish, diabolical, extreme. It’s fair to wonder what those words actually mean, and which book is right for you.

There’s no official scale

The first thing to know is that there’s no shared standard. Each newspaper and publisher decides for itself what “tough” means. One book’s “hard” can feel like another’s “medium,” and a newspaper’s idea of hard may not match a puzzle book’s.

So treat the labels as a rough guide within a single book or paper, not as a fixed measure across all of them.

What the words usually mean

Even without a standard, most publishers use the levels in a similar spirit. Here’s what you can generally expect.

Easy, gentle, or beginner. You can almost always find a number to place by scanning rows, columns, and boxes. Pencil marks are rarely needed. These are a pleasant warm-up, and a good place to build steady habits.

Moderate or medium. You’ll hit a few spots where scanning alone doesn’t show the next move. You may need to note candidates and spot simple patterns, like a number that’s confined to one row inside a box.

Tough or hard. Expect to work with pencil marks for long stretches. Patterns like pairs and triples come up regularly, and occasionally something bigger, such as an X-Wing.

Fiendish, diabolical, or extreme. These need advanced patterns that connect squares far apart on the grid, sometimes several in one puzzle. Even experienced solvers slow down here. Some puzzles at this level go beyond the techniques most people know.

How to choose

  • If you’re new to sudoku, start with an easy or gentle book. The goal is to make scanning feel automatic.
  • If easy puzzles feel too quick, move up one level, not two. The jump from medium to diabolical can feel like a different game.
  • If you’re finishing most puzzles in a book but getting stuck on a few, you’re at the right level. Those few puzzles are where you’ll learn the most.
  • If you’re getting stuck on most puzzles, step back a level for a while. There’s no prize for struggling.

Many books start each section with easier puzzles and get harder toward the back. Flip to the last few pages before you buy to get a feel for the toughest ones.

Large print and paper quality

A few practical points that matter as much as difficulty:

  • Large-print editions are easier on the eyes and leave more room for pencil marks.
  • Thicker paper stands up better to erasing.
  • Spiral binding lets the book lie flat on a table.

Using the app to gauge a book

If you’re not sure what a book’s labels mean, scan one puzzle from it. The Difficulty screen will show a level from Easy to Expert, along with the techniques that puzzle needs. Do this with a couple of puzzles from the same section, and you’ll get a feel for how that publisher’s labels line up with what you already know.

And if a puzzle needs a technique you haven’t met yet, the Difficulty screen links you straight to its lesson in the Learn tab.

Get the app