Sudoku technique 20 of 21 · Expert

X-Chain

Follow one number’s two-spot links end to end. A chain of one number’s two-spot links forces that number into one of its two ends.

The long form of the Skyscraper and 2-String Kite.

Step by step: X-Chain on a real puzzle

  1. X-Chain, step 1: When one number’s two-spot links form a chain, one of its two ends gets that number.

    When one number’s two-spot links form a chain, one of its two ends gets that number.

    Look at the 3s. Column 3, column 9, and row 1 each have only two spots for a 3.

  2. X-Chain, step 2: Suppose row 1, column 5 isn’t a 3.

    Suppose row 1, column 5 isn’t a 3.

    Then row 1, column 7 is. It shares box 3 with row 2, column 9, so that square isn’t, and column 9’s other spot, row 7, column 9, is.

  3. X-Chain, step 3: Keep going to the end of the chain.

    Keep going to the end of the chain.

    Row 7, column 9 shares row 7 with row 7, column 3, so that square isn’t a 3, and column 3’s other spot, row 6, column 3, is.

  4. X-Chain, step 4: Either row 1, column 5 or row 6, column 3 is a 3.

    Either row 1, column 5 or row 6, column 3 is a 3.

    Row 6, column 5 sees row 1, column 5 in column 5 and row 6, column 3 in row 6, so it can’t be 3.

X-Chain

Watch video

An X-Chain works with just one number. Wherever a row, column, or box has only two spots for that number, one of them must hold it. Link several of those pairs together and you get a chain that forces the number into one of its two ends.

Any square that sees both ends can’t hold that number.

How to spot it

  1. Pick one number and look only at where it can go.
  2. Find a row, column, or box with exactly two spots for it. That’s a strong link: if one spot isn’t the number, the other is.
  3. From the far end of that link, jump to another spot it sees. That’s a weak link: the two can’t both be the number.
  4. From there, follow another strong link. Keep alternating, strong, weak, strong.
  5. End on a strong link. Cross the number out of any square that sees both ends.

Why it works

Suppose the first square isn’t the number. The strong link forces the second square to be it. That square sees the third, so the third isn’t, and the next strong link forces the fourth. Following the chain to the end, the last square must be the number. So either the first square or the last one holds it, and a square that sees both can’t.

Common mistakes

  • Starting or ending on a weak link. Both ends of the chain need to be strong links, or the logic doesn’t reach the ends.
  • Two weak links in a row. Links have to alternate. Two weak links in a row break the chain.
  • Three spots in a unit. A strong link needs exactly two spots for the number in that row, column, or box.

Questions

How is this different from an XY-Chain?

An XY-Chain hops between two-candidate squares and can switch numbers along the way. An X-Chain sticks to one number the whole way.

How does it relate to the Skyscraper and 2-String Kite?

They’re the shortest X-Chains, with just four squares. The Skyscraper and 2-String Kite are worth learning first, and Turbot Fish explains how the family fits together. Longer chains like this one find eliminations those four-square patterns miss.

Get the app