Guide · 3 min read

Pencil marks without the mess

A tidy way to note candidates on paper.

Pencil marks are the small numbers you jot in a square to remind yourself which numbers could still go there. Puzzle solvers often call these possible numbers “candidates.” Used well, pencil marks turn a hard puzzle into a series of small, clear steps. Used carelessly, they turn a clean grid into a gray smudge you can’t read.

Here’s how to keep them useful on paper.

Start late, not early

You don’t need pencil marks for the opening of most puzzles. Scan for easy placements first, as described in “How to start any sudoku.” Every number you place before you start marking is a number you won’t have to erase from a dozen notes later.

When scanning stops giving you new numbers, that’s the time to start.

Give every number a fixed spot

The single most helpful habit is to write each candidate in the same place inside the square every time. Imagine the square divided like a phone keypad:

  • 1, 2, and 3 along the top
  • 4, 5, and 6 across the middle
  • 7, 8, and 9 along the bottom

So a 1 always goes in the top-left corner of the square, a 5 always sits in the middle, and a 9 is always in the bottom-right corner.

This has two big benefits. You can see at a glance which numbers are noted without reading each one. And when you look along a row for, say, every possible 7, your eye only has to check the bottom-left corner of each square.

Write small and light

  • Use a sharp pencil, not a pen. You’ll be erasing.
  • Write your candidates much smaller than your answers, so the two never get confused.
  • Press lightly. A light mark erases cleanly and won’t leave a ghost behind.
  • A soft eraser, or the eraser on a mechanical pencil, is easier on newsprint than a hard rubber one.

Mark one number at a time

Rather than filling in every possible number for every square at once, work through the grid one number at a time. Take all the 1s, then all the 2s, and so on. It’s quicker, and you’re less likely to miss a spot.

Some solvers go even lighter and only note a number in a box when it has just two possible squares there. That keeps the grid very clean, though you may need fuller notes later in tougher puzzles.

Update as you go

The most common pencil-mark mistake isn’t a wrong note. It’s a stale one. Every time you place a number, that number can no longer be a candidate anywhere else in the same row, column, or box.

Make it a habit: place a number, then immediately erase that number from the notes in its row, its column, and its box. Three quick sweeps. If you skip this, you’ll later “find” moves that aren’t real.

When the grid gets crowded

If a puzzle’s notes have become unreadable, it can be worth starting fresh. Erase all the pencil marks, keep your answers, and re-mark from scratch. It takes a few minutes, but the clean notes often show you the next step right away.

If you scanned the puzzle into the app, you can also print a fresh copy with the numbers you’ve already placed shown in blue, and carry on from a clean page.

What good notes let you see

Tidy notes make patterns visible. Two squares in a row that can each only be 3 or 8, for example, mean no other square in that row can be a 3 or an 8. Our Learn tab covers this as a Naked Pair. Patterns like that are almost impossible to spot in messy notes, and easy to see in neat ones.

In column 1, two squares can only be 5 or 9. No other square in the column can be either.
In column 1, two squares can only be 5 or 9. No other square in the column can be either.
Get the app